Evidence: how to estimate your home’s market value

A grievance rests on one number: your estimate of what your home was worth on January 4, 2027, the date the county’s value is set as of.1 For a house, the county and New York State both point to the same method, which is comparing it with similar homes that sold recently.2, 3

About the year. A grievance filed in early 2027 is for the 2028/29 tax year. Nassau County labels each cycle by the tax year it changes, and the first bill this one touches is the October 2028 school tax bill. Why the label runs ahead

The number you are estimating

The county defines market value as the most probable price a property would sell for if offered for sale under ordinary circumstances.2 Its assessment is based on value as of January 4, 2027, so that is the date your own estimate should describe.1

The county says to decide whether to appeal by putting its market value for your property next to your own estimate.4 You do not have to work out how the county reached its figure, or show where it went wrong. ARC considers the value you claim and whatever you provide to support it.2

Comparable sales: the state’s method

New York State publishes a guide to estimating a home’s market value. It is written for homeowners across the state, not for Nassau in particular, and it recommends the sales comparison approach.3 In outline:

  1. Find recent sales of similar homes nearby. The state suggests at least three, sold under normal conditions and not by a buyer or seller under pressure.3
  2. Check that each one is really comparable. The traits the state lists are lot size, square footage, home style, age and location.3
  3. Adjust for the differences. No sale will match exactly. For each one, estimate what it would have sold for if it had matched your home: lower if it has something yours lacks, higher if yours has the advantage.3
  4. Read your estimate off the adjusted prices. The adjusted sales give you a range for your own home’s value.3

Where to find sales

  • The county’s own sale search. AROW, the county’s online filing system, has a Sale Locator for residential sales. It works without an account.2 See the AROW walkthrough.
  • The state’s list. Assessors’ offices, municipal offices or websites, online sales databases, local newspapers and real estate agents.3

What to attach

The instructions for each application form list any documents that are required for particular property types and claims.2 The county says the forms for this cycle will be posted on January 4, 2027, so check the instructions then.5

Beyond that, you may attach anything you believe is relevant. Online, the county accepts Word documents, spreadsheets, digital photographs and scanned images; no video files.2 A grid of your comparable sales, with addresses, sale dates, prices and your adjustments, is the kind of thing the state’s guide has in mind.3

One exception: supporting documents for a form AR3 claim, which covers tax class and exemptions, go to the Department of Assessment and not to ARC.2

Choose the number with care

The estimate on your application sets a ceiling. If you later take the case to small claims review, you cannot ask for a bigger reduction than the one you asked the county for.2 New York State gives the same warning about its own grievance form, which is used outside Nassau: you may be barred from a larger reduction than the one you request.6

So file the value your sales support, and be able to show how you got there.

Who looks at it

Applications are reviewed by professional appraisers and other qualified professionals who are members or employees of the commission.2 You do not have to appear in person. Your case is the information you send with the application.2

Next: how to file, or see what the gap might be worth with the calculator.

Quick answers

Do I need an appraisal to file a Nassau County tax grievance?

The county’s list of what you need to file does not include one. It asks for your own estimate of market value.1 You may attach any information you think supports that estimate.2

How many comparable sales do I need?

The county’s pages do not set a number. New York State’s guide for homeowners suggests finding at least three.3

Sources

  1. ARC 2028-29 brochure nassaucountyny.gov
  2. ARC Frequently Asked Questions nassaucountyny.gov
  3. NYS How to estimate market value tax.ny.gov
  4. How to Appeal Your Assessment nassaucountyny.gov
  5. ARC Forms and Instructions nassaucountyny.gov
  6. NYS How to complete the grievance form tax.ny.gov

Last checked: