Small Claims Assessment Review (SCAR) in Nassau County
SCAR is a low-cost court review you can ask for after you have filed a grievance with the county and are not satisfied with the result.1, 2 It is for people who own and live in a one-, two- or three-family home or a Class 1 condo, it costs $30 to file, and it cannot give you more than you asked the county for.1, 2
About the year. A grievance filed in early 2027 is for the 2028/29 tax year. Nassau County labels each cycle by the tax year it changes, and the first bill this one touches is the October 2028 school tax bill. Why the label runs ahead
Who can use it
- You own and live in the home. It must be a one-, two- or three-family home or a Class 1 condo unit, used only as a residence.1, 2
- You filed with the county first. SCAR is open only to people who applied to the Assessment Review Commission (ARC) for that year.2 A withdrawn application does not count.3
- You did not accept a settlement. If you stipulated to a reduction, court review is closed for that year.2
The county’s FAQ says property used partly for business, and vacant lots, do not qualify.2
What it costs and what you can ask for
- The fee is $30.1
- Your county application sets the ceiling. You cannot claim a bigger reduction than the one you asked ARC for, and you cannot ask for a change of tax class.2
- A lawyer is optional.2
- The assessment cannot go up. The hearing officer can order it lowered but not raised.1
When to file
SCAR petitions can be filed starting the first business day in April, once the final roll is out.2 For grievances filed in early 2027, the final roll is published April 3, 2028.4
The last day the county publishes for this cycle is May 1, 2028.4, 5, 6
The last day is written three ways. ARC’s brochure, calendar and dates table give May 1, 2028 for this cycle.4, 5, 6 The county’s general SCAR page gives a rule instead: the last business day in April, or within 30 days of ARC’s decision if ARC decides after April 1.1, 7 New York State’s wording is within 30 days of the filing of the final assessment roll or of the notice of that filing, whichever is later.8 The last weekday of April that year is Friday, April 28, 2028, and a petition filed by then is on time under all three. If you need the later date, confirm it with the County Clerk or ARC (516-571-3214) first.
How to file
Petitions are filed with the Nassau County Clerk, not with ARC.1, 2 The Clerk posts the petition form and filing instructions.9 When we last checked, that page still showed the previous year’s filing period, so its dates are last year’s. The steps below are as the page gave them on the date at the bottom of this page.
From the Clerk’s instructions:9
- Online or on paper. People filing without a lawyer are not required to file electronically.
- On paper. The original petition and one copy, with the fee by check or money order payable to the Nassau County Clerk, mailed to the Clerk’s Division of Court Records (Room 108) or left in the drop box in the lobby of the Clerk’s office.
- Copies. After filing, a copy goes to each of these: the County Assessor (240 Old Country Road, 4th Floor, Mineola), your school district, and your incorporated village if you have one.
County employees cannot help you fill in the papers.2 The New York State courts have their own page on SCAR.8
The hearing and the decision
A court-appointed referee holds the hearing. State law requires an answer within 30 days after the hearing.1
The Clerk’s instructions say the petition should include supporting statements, records and other relevant information.9 The evidence page covers how to build an estimate of market value and the sales that support it.
The other court route
The alternative to SCAR is a tax certiorari proceeding in New York State Supreme Court under Article 7 of the Real Property Tax Law, for which the state recommends a private attorney.8 The county notes that SCAR costs considerably less.1
Before any of this comes the county’s own decision, and before that, the filing deadline.
Quick answers
How much does SCAR cost in Nassau County?
The filing fee is $30.1
Do I need a lawyer for SCAR?
No. The county describes SCAR as a review most homeowners can pursue on their own, without an attorney or representative.2
Can I file SCAR if I accepted the county’s offer?
No. Court review is open only if you applied to the county and did not stipulate to a reduction.2
Sources
- Nassau Small Claims Assessment Review nassaucountyny.gov
- ARC Frequently Asked Questions nassaucountyny.gov
- Form AR12 (county copy) nassaucountyny.gov
- ARC 2028-29 brochure nassaucountyny.gov
- Assessment Review Calendar nassaucountyny.gov
- Nassau County Assessment Review Dates nassaucountyny.gov
- Department of Assessment Important Dates nassaucountyny.gov
- NYS Grievance procedures tax.ny.gov
- County Clerk SCAR E-Filing Instructions nassaucountyny.gov
Last checked: